This is a Tri-Art, a combination or
Richter (the woman),
Rembrandt (St, George) and
Delvaux, (the train.). Whether I am setting a precedent and my renditions are going to get more complicated, I know not. But this speaks to me of memory, of the past coming at you, and on that count is fitting for what follows below.
I'm reposting a piece I wrote about my mother, called "The Fate of Ping." Of course, I had to do a quick readthough first, and I ended up rewriting a lot of it. I'm thinking that perhaps it reads almost as an excerpt of a longer memoir, and that's okay. That's probably exactly where it'll end up eventually.
Happy Mother's Day, and if you read all the way until the end, you'll see just how much I cherish them.
The Fate of Ping
My mother is terribly afraid of heights, but as children we never knew it. She would grit her teeth and wave as her brood madly ascended trees and climbed to other death-defying heights. One such occurrence was captured by a photograph taken at the very top of a French aqueduct--Le Pont du Gard. In the photo there is no evidence that we children are supported by any structure whatsoever. All that can be seen behind us is the sky and in the distance, the Valley of the Gardon , stretching vertiginously behind us.
From below on terra firma, my mother watched, her heart in her mouth and her arms full of sweaters we plied onto her while we raced to touch the summer sky. I imagine she must have hugged tightly to those sweaters that she had knitted herself, relieved to have something to hold onto as she closed her eyes and counted to 10, praying that when she opened them again we would be back to earth swarming around her. Then she could count to a mere 5, one for each of us, and breathe again.
Another fear my mother divulged when it was too late in life to pass on to us was an intense phobia of having her head below water. My father put an above-ground 3-foot pool in our backyard in 1964, where it stood for three summers, and we were all soon inebriated for life with the joys of swimming--the only sport which came easily to my otherwise unathletic father. My mother took the occasional careful dip, but was mostly consigned to making sure we didn't swim until ½ hour after eating. (This has since been reported as a myth, but I will believe it on my deathbed.)
Then there were the dogs. The French are, in general, fairly dog-friendly, but my mother's father was not among them. He owned a shirt-store in Avignon, a small southern French city known for its ramparts and Pope's Palace, and had the mindset of a provincial merchant. Life was full of duties and responsibilities, a dog would have made the world heavier for him, not lighter. My mother didn't exactly fear dogs, but neither had she any experience of the boundless affection and unconditional love they bring. Her acquiescence to our having them was purely an act of maternal love for us.
In 1962, friends of my parents went to spend a year in Europe and let us housesit for the year, rent-free. It was a dramatic house that aspired to a Frank Lloyd Wright look and succeeded admirably. It was at the edge of a forest remnant in the hills of Montgomery County, not far from Washington D.C., amidst the kind of semi-rural sprawl where puppies were born at neighbors' houses and brought home by kids before Mom and Dad could say no. From somewhere or another we adopted a pair of beagle/basset mixes, who we named Ruffy and Tuffy--or perhaps they adopted us. They were emotionally promiscuous dogs who may have been pretending to belong as well to other families that occupied homes at the other side of the woods. At least that seemed the least painful explanation for their disappearance soon before we were due to move.
A few miles away, at our new house at West Ritchie Parkway, we came into a black cocker spaniel mix named Zorro, no doubt named by my brother Luke, who loved the character and was starting to discover he could be quite bossy and get away with it. No one can recollect the reason or manner of Zorro's death, but I am sure we were upset about it. When we met the Sagans, we kids were pining for a new dog.
The Sagans were like us, in that the mother was a European who came here after the war and definitely wore the pants in the family. Ginetta Sagan was short and fiery, an Italian Edith Piaf with a story as dramatic as one would imagine for a woman who would later co-found the Calfornia chapter of Amnesty International. My mother may have been the first kindred spirit Ginetta met in American Suburbia, someone for whom occupation, torture and collaboration were not just abstract concepts but things that had happened to people they knew, and in Ginetta's case, to her.
I have a visual in my head that may be a genuine memory, or may be the product of my imagination, implanted retroactively after hearing my mother tell me Ginetta's story. Whichever its provenance, it resides now in my cerebral cortex. My mother and Ginetta had just finished an outdoor summer lunch from which the kids were excused after the introduction of salad and cheese and adult conversation. I suppose I played with the other kids for a while, then drifted back to the screen door in the kitchen, and watched the two mothers without being noticed.
When I was a child, I wanted terribly to understand what adults were talking about. Or maybe it was more that I thought there would be some sort of test when I hit twelve or so, and if I didn't study I would be doomed to a life of confusion and failure. I remember at 6 or 7, when I was still small enough to fit in the little basin behind the front seat, where those in the back usually put their feet... For some reason, I loved to ride there, being an inordinately small child who loved the cozyness of tight spaces. I distinctly remember listening to my parents discuss the "mortgage." I was both fascinated and filled with trepidation. How was I ever going to understand such things?
So there, through the screen door, I watched my mother with Ginetta, and even though they would probably have been speaking French, I truly thought if I listened hard enough, well enough, with enough willingness and concentration, I would understand.
But in this case, I think the emotional understanding I derived from what I saw counted for far more. The image that I return to, again and again, is that of Ginetta crying, her arms splayed on the table, her head pitched forward on her hands. My mother told me later she had just recounted the story of her harrowing capture by the Nazis, her torture, her escape, the murder of her parents. And seated across from her, my mother, tears in her eyes, saying nothing because she knew that at that very moment, Ginetta needed most simply to be heard. I suspect as well that their acquaintance was still too new for my mother to console her physically, though unquestionably, they would be forever close thereafter.
And then, suddenly, plop! into Ginetta's lap jumped her Pekinese dog, which she'd brought over along with her children. The dog instinctively knew to console her mistress, and in that way that dogs do because they are dogs, broke the tension. I think at the moment, my mother understood them in a new way.
Soon after we got a Pekinese from the Sagans. I remember Dr. Sagan, Ginetta's husband, telling me that Pekinese once had very long noses, but had been made to compete in a great race by a Chinese Emperor. According to Leonard, one of them was so fast he could not stop at the finish line and rammed into the Great Wall of China, smushing his long nose into the form we knew ever since and after, and in doing so becoming the procreator of all future Pekinese.
The story delighted me as I could easily repeat it. Leonard knew how to talk to kids, he had three great boys upon whom I had huge crushes. I thought they were so much cooler than we would ever be. They lived in a huge old Victorian in the center of Rockville that I would check at great length for secret panels when we visited. When that was finished we'd watch Mission Impossible. What could be cooler than that theme music and the tape self-destructing? Leonard was not a practicing medical doctor, but he had an M.D. and he agreed to see me at my mother's request when I complained of severe headaches.
The headaches were quite real, I still remember them. But true as well was that they did seemed to occur exclusively on Sundays. It didn't take long for Leonard to figure out I had a case of the Catholic Church. I don't think I objected to the theology, but I was hopelessly bored. I tried so hard to understand the sermons, as I did all things adult, but it was as impenetrable as my parents' discussion of the mortgage. I was allowed to stop going to church, and the headaches went away. This must have been when I started perusing the Sunday New York Times along with my father.
Perhaps because my parents had papered the walls lining the stairs with maps, I was enthralled with geography. If I couldn't grasp the politics of Vietnam I could at least find it in the atlas, which I would pore over, imagining what life in Botswana or Bogota was like. From the map I'd go to the World Book, and just start reading. My father would patiently answer my questions, even though I had invaded the only private time he had all week. Sometimes he'd grab the globe and give me a place to find, and while I searched he could finish The Week in Review.
We named our new Pekinese Puff, and fell madly in love with her. Puff, like most small dogs, thought she was huge, in fact Puff thought she was the Empress Dowager of our household--her kingdom. For the first time, our canine companion was not an all-purpose mutt. Puff had papers, she was a handsome and stately purebred. Our neighbor Mrs. Timmons, who bred championship pugs for competition, even said so. I don't know if she was the one who encouraged us to breed Puff, but perhaps the fact that she was across the street gave us the courage to try.
Somehow a stud was found, and a date set in our cellar. Being small of course, Pekinese tend toward small litters, and the agreement was we'd keep one puppy, they'd keep one, and I have no idea what we agreed on for any improbable third. In any event, coitus was so successful my mother had to call Mrs. Timmons and ask how to get them apart. I don't know if it was a suction thing or what, but my poor mother spent a good hour massaging the pair till they unstuck. (The two Pekinese were rather Siamese for a while there.) For someone who had no background with dogs or dogbreeding, it was rather an intense baptism of fire for her.
We still have the super-8 films we took of the birth of Puff's three offspring. I think we filmed it so my parents could put to bed any lingering fears that we didn't fully understand how reproduction worked. (Was that ever wishful thinking. As if what a kid wanted to know is what ends the process instead of what begins it.) . But it occurs to me now that the birth may have had more impact on my mother because she was so very present at the conception. If she couldn't relate to Puff as a dog, she could relate to her as a mother.
We named to the two males Ming and Ling, and the third, a female, Ping. Immediately we noticed that the boys were suckling, and Ling was trying, but was being pushed away by Puff, who knew before we did that something was wrong with her. Mrs. Timmons was summoned, she called her vet, the vet made a quick diagnosis that there was an obstruction in Ping's throat, or the muscles were not well enough developed, or something like that.
The doctor held out a small hope that hand-feeding might work; probably more to placate us than because he believed it. My mother tried for two days, watching poor Ping suckle desperately, but nothing seemed to be going down. There was nothing else to do but let her die.
The entire situation was unacceptable to me. Lapsed Catholic that I was, God was already on thin ice with me. I decided then and there that if there was a God, he was either too cruel or too powerless to be worthy of worship. How could he possibly allow a puppy to be born just to starve to death?
Two days later, I came home from school to find my mother with tears streaming down her face. Ping had died. My mother was not crying because of that. She was crying, she told me, because she hadn't been brave enough to drown Ping first, and put her out of her misery. I don't know whether this had to do with her own phobia of having her head below water, but I doubt I could do it either.
On a recent visit to my Mother where she now lives in upstate New York, she asked me to go through her papers. On the form given out in a packet provided by her assisted living center about end-of-life plans, memorials, and the like, there is a question that reads: "Is there something about you that you'd like to be most remembered for?"
And in the space below, my mother had written: "That I was a kind person."
That day back in 1966, when I was in class with all my siblings, my mother had wrestled with one of the most fundamental human paradoxes. Sometimes kindness does not look or feel like kindness at all. Sometimes kindness can feel a lot like cruelty.
I never quite made it back to the Catholic Church, but I retain a belief in at least one scriptural teaching: "Bless the Beast and the Children." But to it I would add: "the Mothers."
MCO 2008